Choosing a scented nail polish set for a girl is a tradeoff between plenty of colors, larger bottles, and a more compact starter collection. I rank the 24-piece value pack first for its mix of glitter and shiny finishes, and the Piggy Paint Lucky Lollipop set next for its larger 0.25-ounce bottles. Piggy Paint’s four-color fruity set is my pick for a smaller, straightforward color lineup.
Get beauty and skincare favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
All three options use water-based formulas and offer scented shades, but their scale and handling needs differ. The large set suits shared play and frequent color changes; the two Piggy Paint sets are more focused, with just four shades each. I’d choose based on whether variety or bottle capacity matters more—and keep expectations realistic about wear, since these are kid-oriented formulas rather than long-wear salon polish.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The 24-piece value pack is the clear choice for the widest color and finish range, with 12 glitter and 12 shiny polishes in a handled case.
- Piggy Paint Lucky Lollipop has four colors like the other Piggy Paint set, but its 0.25-ounce bottles are larger than the 0.12-ounce bottles in the fruity color set.
- The fruity Piggy Paint set names four distinct shades—grape, watermelon, strawberry, and blueberry—but offers less variety than the 24-piece pack.
- All three sets are water-based and scented; the provided details describe kid-friendly formulas, but do not promise the wear of traditional solvent-based polish.
- Drying expectations vary: the fruity Piggy Paint set calls for blow-drying for best wear, while Lucky Lollipop notes air drying and blow-drying, so adult help may be useful.
| 24pc Scented Nail Polish Value Pack – Shiny & Glitter Shades |  | Best Overall for Variety | Polish count: 24 polishes | Formula: Water-based, scented, non-toxic | Finishes: 12 glitter and 12 shiny | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Piggy Paint Nail Polish, Non-Toxic – Scented Lucky Lollipop (4 Color Set) |  | Best for Larger Bottles | Colors: Bubble Gum Bash, Magical Melon, Grouchy Grape, Cupcake Cutie | Polish count: 4 colors | Bottle size: 0.25 oz (7.4 ml) each | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Piggy Paint Nail Polish, Non-Toxic, Natural, Vegan – 4 Color Set |  | Best for a Simple Fruity Palette | Colors: Giggly Grape, Wild Watermelon, Sassy Strawberry, Brave Blueberry | Polish count: 4 colors | Bottle size: 0.12 oz (3.5 ml) each | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| scented nail polish sets for girl | Polish count | Formula | Drying | Colors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24pc Scented Nail Polish Value | 24 polishes | Water-based, scented, non-toxic | Described as quick-drying | — |
| Piggy Paint Nail Polish | 4 colors | Water-based, non-toxic, scented | — | Bubble Gum Bash, Magical Melon, Grouchy Grape, Cupcake Cutie |
| Piggy Paint Nail Polish | 4 colors | Water-based, non-toxic, vegan, scented | Described as quick-drying | Giggly Grape, Wild Watermelon, Sassy Strawberry, Brave Blueberry |
More Details on Our Top Picks
24pc Scented Nail Polish Value Pack – Shiny & Glitter Shades
I rank this set first because it solves the biggest choice problem in this group: how to offer plenty of ways to change a manicure without buying several separate kits. It includes 24 fruity-scented polishes, divided evenly between shiny and glitter finishes, so a child can choose not only a color but also the look of the finished nails. Compared with either four-color Piggy Paint option, it offers much more room for experimenting, coordinating shades, or sharing during a supervised craft session.
The handled portable case also gives the large collection a practical advantage. Twenty-four bottles are harder to keep organized than four, and a case gives them a designated place between uses. The formula is described as water-based, non-toxic, formaldehyde-free, and quick-drying. Those details make the pack appealing for kid-focused use, though I would not read them as a guarantee against irritation or mess. Adult help remains sensible, especially with young children.
The tradeoff is wear: the supplied details say the polish may chip sooner than traditional solvent-based formulas. That matters if the goal is a manicure that stays neat through several days of active play. The sheer number of shades may also be unnecessary for a child who prefers a small, familiar palette. Compared with Lucky Lollipop, this pack prioritizes breadth and finish variety over larger individual bottles; compared with the fruity four-color Piggy Paint set, it is less compact but much more flexible.
I’d choose it for a family that wants a full-color activity set with glitter and glossy-looking options in one case. I’d skip it if storage space is tight, if only a few shades will get used, or if long wear matters more than a kid-oriented water-based formula.
Pros:- 24 fruity-scented polishes provide the broadest selection in this roundup.
- An even split of 12 glitter and 12 shiny finishes supports different manicure styles.
- The handled case helps keep a large collection together and portable.
- Water-based, quick-drying, non-toxic, and formaldehyde-free formula is described for kid-friendly use.
Cons:- May chip more quickly than traditional solvent-based polish.
- Twenty-four bottles take up more storage space than either four-color Piggy Paint set.
- The product details do not specify bottle size or the individual scent for every shade.
Best for: Girls who enjoy trying many colors and alternating between glitter and shiny finishes, especially when a parent wants one organized set for creative nail play.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a compact four-shade kit, children who will use only a few colors, or anyone prioritizing longer wear over a water-based formula.
- Polish count:24 polishes
- Formula:Water-based, scented, non-toxic
- Finishes:12 glitter and 12 shiny
- Storage:Portable case with handle
- Drying:Described as quick-drying
- Safety details:Formaldehyde-free; described as suitable for sensitive skin
- Wear tradeoff:May chip more quickly than traditional solvent-based formulas
Our verdict“I’d pick this set for the strongest combination of scented color variety, mixed finishes, and storage, provided a large kit matters more than extended wear.”
Piggy Paint Nail Polish, Non-Toxic – Scented Lucky Lollipop (4 Color Set)
Lucky Lollipop is my second pick for buyers who would rather have more polish per shade than a wide color count. The set contains four scented colors, but its bottles are 0.25 ounces each—larger than the 0.12-ounce bottles in Piggy Paint’s Giggly Grape, Wild Watermelon, Sassy Strawberry, and Brave Blueberry set. That makes Lucky Lollipop the more appealing of the two Piggy Paint choices for a child who returns to the same colors often.
Its shades—Bubble Gum Bash, Magical Melon, Grouchy Grape, and Cupcake Cutie—give the set a playful, candy-inspired identity. The formula is described as water-based, non-toxic, and vegan, and the product information says it is odorless while also listing the polishes as scented. Since those descriptors can leave the exact scent experience unclear, I would not choose this set based on a promise of strong fragrance. It is better understood as a four-color scented option with a kid-focused formula.
Compared with the 24-piece value pack, Lucky Lollipop is much less expansive: there is no stated glitter-and-shiny split, and only four colors are included. That smaller palette is easier to keep organized, but it gives less opportunity to experiment. Its instructions also call for air drying and blow-drying for best wear, while the fruity Piggy Paint set specifically mentions blow-drying for best wear. Either way, it asks for more patience and adult involvement than simply painting and moving on. Multiple coats may be needed for full coverage, adding to that wait.
I’d choose Lucky Lollipop when bottle size matters more than shade count and a compact set is preferable to the 24-piece case. I’d pass if a child wants many colors, a stated range of finishes, or a very quick manicure routine. Its larger bottles help distinguish it from the other four-color option, but the limited palette remains a real constraint.
Pros:- Four playful named colors create an easy-to-understand small palette.
- At 0.25 ounces each, the bottles are larger than those in the other four-color Piggy Paint set.
- The formula is described as water-based, non-toxic, and vegan.
- A compact collection takes less space than the 24-polish handled case.
Cons:- Only four colors are included, far fewer than the 24-piece value pack.
- The supplied details say air drying and blow-drying help with wear.
- Multiple coats may be needed for full coverage.
Best for: Children who prefer a compact four-shade collection and are likely to reuse favorite colors, with a parent available to help follow drying directions.
Not ideal for: Buyers looking for the broadest range of shades or finishes, or families who want a simple routine without extra drying steps or multiple coats.
- Colors:Bubble Gum Bash, Magical Melon, Grouchy Grape, Cupcake Cutie
- Polish count:4 colors
- Bottle size:0.25 oz (7.4 ml) each
- Formula:Water-based, non-toxic, scented
- Other formula detail:Described as vegan and odorless
- Drying guidance:Air drying; blow-drying is suggested for best wear
- Coverage note:May need multiple coats for full coverage
Our verdict“I’d choose Lucky Lollipop over the other four-color set when larger bottles matter most, but not when a wide range of colors or finishes is the priority.”
Piggy Paint Nail Polish, Non-Toxic, Natural, Vegan – 4 Color Set
This Piggy Paint set makes sense when a child wants a small, clearly themed color selection rather than a case full of choices. Its four shades are Giggly Grape, Wild Watermelon, Sassy Strawberry, and Brave Blueberry. Those fruit-forward names make the palette easy to describe and choose from, while the water-based, scented formula keeps the set aligned with the main appeal of this roundup.
Compared with the 24-piece value pack, this is a much smaller commitment in color variety and storage. That can be a plus for a beginner or a child who tends to settle on a few favorite shades. The tradeoff becomes clearer beside Lucky Lollipop: both have four colors, but this set’s bottles are 0.12 ounces each, less than half the stated 0.25-ounce bottles in Lucky Lollipop. If frequent use is likely, the larger-bottle set offers more polish per color.
The product description calls the formula non-toxic, natural, vegan, and suitable for kids, pets, and all ages. It also says it dries quickly, yet recommends blow-drying for best wear. I would follow the provided directions rather than assume the polish will be fully set as soon as it feels dry. The small bottles and limited palette make it easy to start with a few colors, but frequent reuse may mean reaching the end of a shade sooner than with Lucky Lollipop.
I’d pick this set for a child who likes fruity color names and does not need a large range or substantial bottle capacity. I’d skip it if a wide selection is the point of the purchase, or if bottle size is the deciding factor. Against the other Piggy Paint set, its strongest distinction is its named grape, watermelon, strawberry, and blueberry palette, not extra quantity.
Pros:- Four distinct fruit-inspired shades give the palette a clear theme.
- Scented, water-based formula is described as non-toxic and vegan.
- The compact four-color selection is simpler to store and manage than the 24-piece set.
- The product details describe application as easy and drying as quick.
Cons:- Each 0.12-ounce bottle is smaller than the Lucky Lollipop bottles.
- The set offers only four colors and no stated finish variety.
- Blow-drying is recommended for best wear.
Best for: Beginners and children who want four familiar fruit-inspired colors in a small set, with a parent able to help with drying.
Not ideal for: Children who want many shades or finishes, frequent polish users who would benefit from larger bottles, or anyone seeking wear without blow-drying guidance.
- Colors:Giggly Grape, Wild Watermelon, Sassy Strawberry, Brave Blueberry
- Polish count:4 colors
- Bottle size:0.12 oz (3.5 ml) each
- Formula:Water-based, non-toxic, vegan, scented
- Drying:Described as quick-drying
- Wear guidance:Blow-drying is recommended for best wear
- Named scent themes:Grape, watermelon, strawberry, and blueberry
Our verdict“I’d choose this as a simple fruity starter set, but Lucky Lollipop is the better Piggy Paint pick if larger bottles are more useful.”
How We Picked
I compared these three sets on the details that make a difference for girls’ scented nail polish play: how many shades are included, what kinds of finishes are offered, bottle size, portability, and the amount of drying guidance the product description gives. Because the lineup includes one 24-polish set and two four-polish sets, I did not treat a larger count as an automatic win. A smaller kit can make more sense when bottle capacity or a defined color theme matters more than having many choices.
I gave the 24-piece pack the leading position because it combines fruity scents, two finish types, and a portable handled case in one set. Lucky Lollipop ranks second for its larger 0.25-ounce bottles, which offer more polish per color than the other four-color Piggy Paint set. The fruity Piggy Paint set ranks third: its named shades make the palette easy to understand, but its smaller 0.12-ounce bottles and limited selection give it less flexibility. I also noted the stated wear and drying tradeoffs rather than assuming water-based polish will behave like conventional nail lacquer.
I rely on the supplied product information and avoid adding unsupported claims about scent strength, exact drying times, durability, or suitability for a particular skin condition. Descriptions such as non-toxic and kid-friendly are useful product details, but they do not replace adult supervision or a check of the package directions. My ranking reflects each set’s fit for this roundup, not a claim that every child will prefer the same scents or finishes.
| scented nail polish sets for girl | Formula | Colors |
|---|---|---|
| 24pc Scented Nail Polish Value | Water-based, scented, non-toxic | — |
| Piggy Paint Nail Polish | Water-based, non-toxic, scented | Bubble Gum Bash, Magical Melon, Grouchy Grape, Cupcake Cutie |
| Piggy Paint Nail Polish | Water-based, non-toxic, vegan, scented | Giggly Grape, Wild Watermelon, Sassy Strawberry, Brave Blueberry |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Scented Nail Polish Sets For Girls
I’d narrow the choice by deciding what the child will value most: plenty of colors, more polish in each bottle, or a compact palette that is easy to manage.Choose between variety and bottle capacity
The 24-piece pack is the only option here that makes variety the main event: 24 shades, split evenly between glitter and shiny finishes. That range is useful when a child likes changing looks or when the set will be shared. Both Piggy Paint choices stop at four colors, so they suit a more limited palette. Between those two, Lucky Lollipop has 0.25-ounce bottles, while the fruity set has 0.12-ounce bottles. If the same shades will be used repeatedly, the larger bottles may be a better fit than the smaller fruit-themed set.
Treat scent and names as different buying cues
All three products are described as scented, but the supplied details do not give a direct scent-strength comparison. The fruity 24-piece pack is described broadly, without a scent listed for every shade. The four-color Piggy Paint set names grape, watermelon, strawberry, and blueberry shades, while Lucky Lollipop uses playful names such as Bubble Gum Bash and Cupcake Cutie. I’d choose by the color theme the child likes, not by assuming one kit will smell stronger or last longer.
Set expectations about drying and wear
Water-based polish is a shared feature, but the drying notes are not identical. The 24-piece set is described as quick-drying. The fruity Piggy Paint set says blow-drying is helpful for best wear, and Lucky Lollipop lists air drying with blow-drying guidance. Lucky Lollipop may also need multiple coats for full coverage. I’d plan a calm activity around application and follow each product’s directions. The 24-piece pack also notes that it may chip sooner than traditional solvent-based polish, so I would not buy any of these expecting a long-wear manicure.
Match the kit to the child and the storage space
A large handled case can make the 24-piece set easier to carry and put away, but it still takes room and includes many bottles to organize. A four-color Piggy Paint set is more manageable for a child who is just starting or prefers a few familiar options. The fruity set is particularly compact because of its smaller bottles; Lucky Lollipop stays compact in color count but provides larger bottles. For all three, an adult should review package directions and supervise younger users rather than relying on broad safety descriptions alone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which set has the most color and finish variety?
The 24-piece Scented Nail Polish Value Pack has the widest selection, with 12 glitter polishes and 12 shiny polishes. The two Piggy Paint sets each include four colors and do not list a comparable glitter-and-shiny split. I’d choose the value pack when changing colors and finishes is the priority.
Which four-color set has the larger bottles?
Piggy Paint Lucky Lollipop lists 0.25-ounce bottles, compared with 0.12-ounce bottles in the Giggly Grape, Wild Watermelon, Sassy Strawberry, and Brave Blueberry set. Both contain four colors, so Lucky Lollipop is the more appealing option when getting more polish per shade matters more than having a fruit-named palette.
Do these sets use water-based polish?
Yes. The 24-piece value pack and both Piggy Paint sets are described as water-based. The listed formulas also include kid-focused details such as non-toxic descriptions, and the 24-piece pack is described as formaldehyde-free. I’d still read the packaging directions and supervise children during application.
Which set is best for a child who wants a small starter collection?
Either four-color Piggy Paint set is more compact in shade count than the 24-piece value pack. The fruity set is a clear match for a child who likes grape, watermelon, strawberry, and blueberry themes. Lucky Lollipop is preferable if the child is likely to reuse favorites and larger 0.25-ounce bottles are useful.
Should I expect these polishes to last like traditional nail polish?
No. The supplied details note that the 24-piece water-based polish may chip sooner than traditional solvent-based formulas. The Piggy Paint listings also give drying guidance, including blow-drying for best wear and, for Lucky Lollipop, the possibility of multiple coats for full coverage. I’d view these as kid-oriented color and play sets rather than long-wear manicure products.
Conclusion
For a child who wants the most options in one purchase, I recommend the 24-piece value pack: its glitter-and-shiny split, fruity scent description, and handled case make it the most versatile set here, with faster chipping as the main tradeoff. For a child who prefers four shades but may use them often, choose Piggy Paint Lucky Lollipop for its larger bottles. For a beginner who likes a straightforward fruit-themed palette and wants smaller bottles, the Giggly Grape, Wild Watermelon, Sassy Strawberry, and Brave Blueberry set is the more focused pick. I’d base the final choice on variety, bottle size, and willingness to follow drying directions—not on an expectation of salon-style wear.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
